In my
mind, soup that you ate for an everyday meal came from a can that made an odd burping
noise as you dumped it into the pot and the most you added was a cup of water.
All I tasted was salt, preservatives and the texture was like gelatin in my mouth.
Then, I moved to the East coast and was desperate for a food
that could warm me from the inside out during the harsh winters or one that
could cool me off during the oppressive summers. My quest lead me into some of
the top restaurants in the city to a few chain restaurants and many lunch dives where I finally discovered fresh tomato basil soup made with a hint of cream and served
with French bread. This launched my love affair with soup. But, I was still naïve
in the many ways soup can be served until a trip to Spain opened my eyes (or
stomach) to how satiating a gazpacho made with ripe, fresh vegetables can be.
Once we moved back home to Texas, I went in pursuit of the perfect
bowl of chicken tortilla soup and the slightly different caldo. Caldo – the Mexican
version of chicken soup - combines a hearty chicken broth with cooked, earthy
vegetables, fresh cilantro and onions added in. In my neck of the woods, the
two soups are very similar although tortilla soup usually has corn tortillas as
a thickening base and a spicy chicken and tomato broth while caldo has the
tortillas on the side and the broth doesn’t have the tomatoes. I have sampled caldo and chicken tortilla soup
at many local restaurants asking for all of the condiments, from the cheese to
the onions, on the side so I can truly taste the wholesome broth and then
determine what needs to be added to give depth to the soup. Only then do I add
lime (as I’ve said before, I’m a citrusholic), cilantro, onion and a pinch of
cheese.
Over the years, I’ve looked for chicken tortilla soup
recipes that combine the best aspects of the restaurant versions I’ve taste tested
and the recipe below covers all of the cornerstones I look for in a tortilla soup.
I found it in a Williams Sonoma soup cookbook called Winter Soups by Ray Overton and I’ve modified the recipe over
the years. The soup starts with corn tortillas as the base followed by a tomato
chicken stock broth that’s full of spice and finished with shredded chicken,
fresh avocado and cilantro. It’s a one-bowl meal that warms you from the heat and makes you sweat from the spice then has you coming back
for a 2nd bowl.
![]() |
| The next soup quest ... ramen. |
![]() |
| My partner in the quest. |







